Skip to main content

Response on Matt's Mind- Follow up to "The Storm"


Matt's interpretation of Kate Choppin's last line in The Storm is an original perspective in that it may be what the elusive author meant with the final statement. The true definition of happiness is up to the viewer, and, with each person holding differing moral standpoints, exceptions, religious restrictions, or polygamous ideals, that happiness is either raw and honest or artificial and a charade. It also forces the reader to analyze morality's toll in the story, for dishonesty and infidelity cannot be forgotten/ 

Matt's specific viewpoint on the happiness stated at the end of the story is different than mine in that it takes into consideration the morality of the situation as well as if the affair were to continue. We did, however share the same disdain for the dishonesty represented in the story. I focused more on how impending truth, future heartbreak, and ignorance being bliss temporarily builds a false happiness that will only lasts momentarily. This could possibly be a realism versus romanticism argument or just a difference in perspective of how emotional pain may heal. Choppin's gravitational final sentence allows for these differing opinions and leaves interpretation up to the reader, which could be what she intended, preserving the reader's take and avoiding choosing sides. 

Choppin's ambiguous "happiness" at the end of the story can be viewed extremely different in modern times where polygamous relationships, divorce, and affairs, are common. This happiness can be viewed as honest, artificial, or just different when coming to terms with a new culture, which may also be a sub theme of Choppin, analyzing how marriage is a changing institution and up to opinion as how it's to be maintained.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Follow Up to Chad D.'s "Understanding Mowing"

Chad's analysis of Mowing  by Robert Frost reveals a major peculiarity in the Imagism genre. Although the reader is forced to give more thought towards the meaning of each word, the overall message of the poem may become clouded in murky translation. Chad's interpretation of the poem is that it may suggest an individual reaps what they sow; I thought it could be focusing on the simplicity and peace in nature and work, and various sources claim the theme is that hard work is rewarding in itself. The imagism and modernist movements in literature granted great works but many are cloudy to interpret and dreary as well. Frost's other works such as The Road Not Taken  or Mending Wall  utilize more words that convey emotion and thought that issues the reader insight into the mind of the narrator as well as aid in unearthing the meaning. However, this may've been what Frost intended, each reader being able to take away the lessons and emotions they received from the writing.
Post a Comment
Read more

Close Reading of Mending Wall

Robert Frost's Mending Wall  provides insight to the thoughts of a landowner on the stone wall that separates his property from his neighbor's. It is clear the narrator is cognizant of the dividing force of this wall, forcing him to question the validity of the partition. After much circumspect evaluation and consideration, Frost comes to the conclusion that "Something there is that doesn't love a wall." This resolution sprouts from his realization that the physical barrier is useless in this specific scenario and brings about unintended repercussions Close Reading Questions: 1.  How is the title of the poem working? What information is it giving? How would the poem be different with a different title? A: The title of the poem, Mending Wall , provides the reader  with the  focus of the poem, of course being the wall. However, what is also essential about the title is how the narrator and his neighbor engage in mending the wall every spring. The poem would...
Post a Comment
Read more

Robert Frost Between Modernism and Realism

Robert Frost, the famous nature poet, is often considered a member of the modernism movement, but he also exhibits key aspects of realism in his writings that are important to realize. Where modernism generates the barrage of questioning traditions and curiosity of seeking understanding through deep thinking, realism seeks to establish truth in the reality of life as it is presented, creating different interpretations. These realist and modernist ideals are established in multiple works of his such as Mending Wall , The Road Not Taken , as well as Fire and Ice. Robert Frost walks the line along both perspectives as his works often derive a natural truth from the real world such as nature or emotion while also using this natural truth to provoke curiosity discovered through contemplation. Many of his narrators discover a truth of the world through their observation of reality but also find themselves in deeper questioning of these truths or traditions that've been established. Fro...
Post a Comment
Read more